About this arrangement

The garden rhyme, with the tune Alfred Moffat printed in 1911. It starts high with the little finger on G and walks down in steady crotchets (quarter notes), with two quavers (eighth notes) for “con-trary” and “does your”. Then the hand has to move: “With” at the end of bar 4 drops to the G below middle C, and bars 5 and 6 climb up from there, A, B, C, for “silver bells” and “cockle-shells”. The last line returns to C position. The left hand plays chords, with single low bass notes in bars 5 and 6 so the hands do not bump.

Practice tip: Practise the drop in bar 4 on its own: hold D, then move the whole hand down so the thumb lands on the low G. Bars 5 and 6 start the same way, so learn one and you know both.

The words

Mary, Mary, quite contrary, How does your garden grow? With silver bells and cockleshells, And pretty maids all in a row.

A short history

Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary is number 19626 in the Roud Folk Song Index. The oldest known version was printed in Tommy Thumb’s Pretty Song Book in the 1740s, and other 18th-century printings call her Mistress Mary and change the last line.

The rhyme has collected many explanations. It has been read as a hidden story about Mary, Queen of Scots, about Queen Mary I, or about the Catholic church, with the silver bells and cockle shells standing for church bells and pilgrims’ badges. None of these has any evidence behind it, and the rhyme has not been found in print before the 18th century, long after those queens had died.

The tune used here is the one Alfred Moffat harmonised for Our Old Nursery Rhymes, published by Augener in London in 1911. James William Elliott’s National Nursery Rhymes of 1870 sets the same words to a different tune.

Quick facts

Tune
Traditional (English, printed 1740s; tune as printed by Alfred Moffat, 1911)
Key
C major
Time signature
4/4
Length
8 bars
Tempo
Lightly, crotchet = 100
Difficulty
Level 3: Notes below middle C (piece 46 of 201)
Type
Nursery rhyme
Hands
Both: melody in the right hand, chords in the left
Copyright
Public domain tune; arrangement by Digital Greenhouse, free for personal and classroom use

Questions and answers

What key is Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary in?
C major, in 4/4 time. There are no sharps or flats in the key signature.
How long is it?
C major, 4/4, 8 bars. The tempo marking is Lightly, crotchet = 100.
Is Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary out of copyright?
Yes. The tune is traditional (English, printed 1740s; tune as printed by Alfred Moffat, 1911). Our piano arrangement is free for personal and classroom use.
What is the hardest part?
Practise the drop in bar 4 on its own: hold D, then move the whole hand down so the thumb lands on the low G. Bars 5 and 6 start the same way, so learn one and you know both.
Can I print it?
Yes. Press Print above to put this piece on its own page, or choose Save as PDF as the printer for a file. It prints on A4 paper; if yours is US Letter, choose US Letter in the box beside Print. The notes are the same size as a printed music book.

← More nursery rhymes  ·  All 201 pieces: piano sheet music for kids

🔒 Runs entirely in your browser: nothing is uploaded and no account is needed. Once loaded, the page and the piano keep working offline.

AI workshops for teams

Get your team confident with AI.

Interactive half-day and full-day workshops in Copilot, Claude or ChatGPT, run at your office - in Sydney, or anywhere we can fly to.